A patient in London has raised serious concerns about the sharing of sensitive therapy notes with thousands of NHS staff, prompting a formal investigation and sparking broader debates about data privacy, patient consent, and the boundaries of confidentiality in mental health care. Source: theguardian.com.
What Happened
Rosanna (not her real name) discovered that detailed notes from her psychotherapy sessions—covering grief and trauma—had been uploaded to her electronic patient record during a routine visit to her general practitioner. The record was accessible to staff across the NHS, including more than 100,000 workers through the London Care Record (LCR).
She said she felt ‘horrified’ to see her private conversations with a therapist on a screen, describing it as if her personal diary had been photocopied and placed in a public library. The revelation came as she was reviewing her medical history, and it triggered a profound sense of violation and loss of control over her personal life.
Her therapy notes were uploaded to the LCR at a time when the NHS is undergoing significant digital transformation, including the rollout of a proposed single patient record. This incident has raised urgent questions about how such sensitive data is collected, stored, and shared, especially when patients are not informed of its visibility to a broad network of staff.
Key Facts
- Her therapy notes were uploaded to the London Care Record (LCR), an electronic system used by up to 140,000 NHS staff, including those from different trusts and specialties.
- The notes included content about her grief and trauma, which she considers deeply personal and emotionally significant.
- She discovered the data was accessible by staff not employed at the hospital trust where she received care—South London and Maudsley NHS Trust (SLaM).
- She paused her bipolar disorder treatment after learning about the data sharing, leaving her without mental health support during a family bereavement.
- Her freedom of information request to SLaM has not yet been responded to, raising concerns about transparency and accountability.
- SLaM admitted that key session content is automatically uploaded to patient records, though it claims no intimate details are shared.
- SLaM says clinicians can limit access to local teams and mask sensitive parts of records to protect privacy.
Background: How Therapy Notes Are Shared
Under current NHS protocols, therapy records are considered part of a patient’s overall medical history. However, the extent of what is shared—and with whom—has not been clearly defined or consistently communicated to patients.
SLaM states that only significant changes, themes, risks, and agreed actions are recorded. These are considered relevant for care coordination and continuity of treatment. For example, if a patient expresses concerns about self-harm or suicidal ideation, such information may be noted and shared to ensure appropriate monitoring.
Yet, patients are not always informed that such details may be visible to a wide network of staff. Rosanna said she was not told her therapy notes would be accessible to tens of thousands of NHS workers. This lack of transparency undermines patient trust and raises ethical concerns about informed consent.
She emphasized that therapy is traditionally considered confidential, with patients only being told when there is a safeguarding risk—such as a threat to themselves or others. In her case, she was not given a clear explanation of what data would be shared or how it would be used, which she argues violates the principle of autonomy in healthcare.
Why It Matters
For patients, especially those with trauma or mental health conditions, the exposure of private conversations can be deeply distressing. The emotional impact of realizing that intimate details of personal struggles—such as grief over a lost loved one—are visible to staff across the NHS is profound.
When a parent was seriously ill and later died, Rosanna said she had no mental health support during that time. She believes her treatment was paused due to a loss of confidence in the system. This highlights a critical gap: patients may be unable to access vital mental health care during periods of crisis, simply because they fear their private disclosures could be exposed.
Her case has prompted questions in Parliament about whether similar data sharing occurs for children’s therapy records. SLaM’s own list includes all events from its child and adolescent mental health services, suggesting that even younger patients may be subject to the same data-sharing practices without explicit consent.
Andy Bell, chief executive of the Centre for Mental Health, said therapy should have a clear boundary between what can be shared and what must remain confidential. He said patients should not be surprised to find personal information on medical records. He added that if patients are discovering information about themselves on the system that they didn’t expect, it suggests that the system is not working as intended.
Responses and Limitations
SLaM has apologised for delays in responding to Rosanna’s concerns and said it prioritises patient confidentiality. It maintains that only key content—such as treatment risks and agreed actions—is shared, and that clinicians can restrict access to local teams.
Yet, Rosanna says she was not informed of the data-sharing policy. She believes patients should have the option to opt out of such sharing. She said: ‘You can’t object to something if you don’t know it’s happening and you haven’t been told.’
Her MP, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, asked the government for guidance on how mental health trusts share therapy notes. Junior health minister James Frith responded that all records ‘relating to direct care’ are shared on a basis of implied consent. This means patients are assumed to agree to sharing, unless explicitly told otherwise. Rosanna argues this creates a gap in transparency and consent.
What to Watch Next
The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has launched an investigation into the case, following a request from former Labour minister Philip Hunt. The inquiry will assess whether the sharing of therapy notes violates data protection laws and whether adequate safeguards exist to protect patient privacy.
It remains unclear whether this incident reflects a broader issue across the NHS. Rosanna says she is concerned other patients, especially children, may be similarly affected. She supports the proposed single patient record under the health bill but believes it should focus on medical details, not therapy session content.
She urges patients to learn about their data rights and to understand what information is shared—and how to protect their privacy. She said: ‘Transparency over what will be on the shared record and the option to opt out is essential.’
Sources & further reading
Featured image: original publisher image. Via original publisher. Image source
